Among the number of befuddling papers I've gotten lately by far the worst of them arrived about a month ago. It was marked IRS or something like that, so I opened it with nearly shaking hands as I rode up in my elevator and as I read it over carefully walking down the dark half open corridor to my apartment my consternation increased. Maybe its just one of those routine things they have to send out to people even if they are not eligible I though to myself, but when I read more carefully my credulity reached to a pique of ire.
I was politely informed that I might be eligible for a stimulus package. You know that paltry three hundred dollars the government might give you back on your taxes, except hears the big thing. I don't PAY taxes! Now I'm not saying I should pay taxes. I haven't lived there for almost the last ten years, and I faithfully pay my taxes to the Japanese government. And when I file my obligatory forms I mark the box that says tax home outside the US. But I still qualify for the refund apparently.
Now most people thing the whole thing is generally speaking a bad idea, were trillions of dollars in debt and spending more every day. Many people think its also a little insulting considering they took the money in the first place. Like a mugger saying OK I'll take this two hundred dollars out of your wallet and hears ten for you so you can get home. But this is Bushes fabulous plan, he gives you three hundred bucks and you'll go out and spend it and the economy will be saved. But how in the world does it help anyone me getting the money. If they take it out of your pocket and send it to me its not like I'm going to spend it in the US. I'll be stimulating the Japanese economy, right?
I really hope I don't get the money. I really really hope they don't send it to me. You've got to know things are getting really out of hand when someone is thinking to the government 'please for the love of god don't send me three hundred dollars.'
But this is why I'm feeling a little ambiguous about the idea of the government running heath care or any other business that has hither to been privatized. There just not to good at running things. If you look at the current state of the education system I think most of us would agree its been run into the ground. In fact it would be a waist of space to list all the things that they've managed to mis manage. Rousseau along with many other philosophers that wrote on idea forms of government insisted that democracy needed to stay small. Among the reasons he mentioned there is the fact that the larger a group gets the larger is the disenfranchised minority. Also that people will loose interest in becoming involved. More to my particular point today, that the larger a body you govern the more and more an apparatus becomes necessary, and the more people that get involved in that apparatus the more space there is for corruption and arbitrary behavior. Petty officials will tend to be petty and inefficient.
And hear we are, do we want it to spread into more fields? Do we want them running the Internet for instance? Its not like most of them understand it. Do we want looking over the shoulders of scientists telling them what to publish? Its not like they understand most science either. Oh well lets just cross our fingers and hope they don't send me the money.


